The Holiday Edit

Red heart-shaped ornament with cut-out letters on a wooden surface

$35.00

Scalloped NYC Cutout Ceramic Ornament

POTTERYGIRLNY

Sold Out

Red candle with 'BOUGIE FUNK' branding on a wooden surface

$20.00

Woodland Trail Candle

BOUGIE FUNK

Three nutcracker-shaped candles on stands with a plain background

$22.00

Nutcracker Candle

MarneyAsh

$6.00

A Charming Holiday Card

BOSS DOTTY PAPER CO.

Heart-shaped ceramic tag with 'NYC' on a wooden surface

$28.00

Stamped NYC Ceramic Ornament

POTTERYGIRLNY

Two heart-shaped 'NYC' cutout charms on a wooden surface.

Green heart-shaped ornament with 'NYC' cutout on a wooden surface

$35.00

NYC Cutout Ceramic Ornament

POTTERYGIRLNY

Sold Out

Ceramic apple-shaped ornament hanging on a christmas tree

$32.00

Brooklyn Apple Ceramic Ornament

POTTERYGIRLNY

$7.00

Holiday Cookies Card

MR. BODDINGTON'S STUDIO

$6.00

Pigeon Hanukkah Letters Card

BOSS DOTTY PAPER CO.

Decorative pigeon ornament on a wooden surface

$25.00

Ceramic Pigeon Ornament

ANNIES POTTERIES

Winter Wonderland Candle - The WonderMart

$30.00

Winter Wonderland Candle

OLYMPIA CRAFTS

Cranberry Spice Room & Linen Spray - The WonderMart

$12.00

Cranberry Spice Room & Linen Spray

HUDSON VALLEY SKIN CARE

Christmas Tree Room & Linen Spray - The WonderMart

$12.00

Christmas Tree Room & Linen Spray

HUDSON VALLEY SKIN CARE

Holiday Skin Care Gift Set - The WonderMart

$48.00

Holiday Skin Care Gift Set

HUDSON VALLEY SKIN CARE

Sold Out

$7.00

Holly White Christmas Tissue Paper

TALKING TABLES

Sold Out

$7.00

Holiday Mushroom Forest Tissue Paper

TALKING TABLES

$7.00

Mistletoe Tissue Paper

TALKING TABLES

Modern Christmas Hand Painted Ornament - The WonderMart

$32.00

Modern Christmas Hand Painted Ornament

LACOTT FINE ART

Pink Winter Jasmine Hand Painted Ornament - The WonderMart

$32.00

Pink Winter Jasmine Hand Painted Ornament

LACOTT FINE ART

Poinsettia in Evergreen Hand Painted Ornament - The WonderMart

$32.00

Poinsettia in Evergreen Hand Painted Ornament

LACOTT FINE ART

$24.00

Ice Skating at Bryant Park Candle

SCENT & SPROUT

$6.00

Holiday Snow Globe Card

IEJ STUDIO

$5.00

Christmas Stocking Card

IEJ STUDIO

Let's Make a Toast Gift Bag - The WonderMart

$6.50

Let's Make a Toast Gift Bag

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$6.00

Retro Floral Dreidel Hanukkah Card

MY DARLIN

$22.00

Holiday Waves Card Set

MY DARLIN

From $6.00

Peace & Love Doves Holiday Card

MY DARLIN

Merry Little Ornaments Holiday Card Set - The WonderMart

$22.00

Merry Little Ornaments Holiday Card Set

MY DARLIN

$9.00

Silver Foil Holiday Gift Tag Sticker Sheet Set

MY DARLIN

$6.00

Wishing You Peace Card

RANI BAN CO

Sold Out

$9.00

Cranberry Woods Soap

MAINLAND VINTAGE

$7.00

Happy Holly-daze Card

HARTLAND CARDS

From $6.00

Happy Holiday Arches Card

HARTLAND CARDS

$9.50

North Pole Headquarters Gift Bag

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$7.00

Christmas in Copenhagen Gift Bag

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$6.00

Tinsel on the Tree Card

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$6.00

Peace and Cocktails Card

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$5.00

Tinsel on the Tree Gift Bag

MR. BODDINGTON'S

Sold Out

$10.00

Ceramic Vase Ornament

LHMC STUDIO

$8.00

Flora Ornament

LHMC STUDIO

$6.00

From My Bar Cart to Yours Card

MR. BODDINGTON'S

$6.00

Charlie's Tree Card

MR. BODDINGTON'S STUDIO

$5.00

Happy Holidays Bar Cart Card

FOOTNOTES

$5.00

Tis The Season To Be Jolly Card

FOOTNOTES

$5.00

Season's Greetings and a Happy New Year Card

FOOTNOTES

$5.00

Holiday Happiness Is All Around Card

THE MEMORABLE IMAGE

$5.00

Winter Bouquet Card

LACOTT FINE ART

$6.00

Holiday Ornament Card

BENJI'S OF BROOKLYN

Green card with white floral pattern and 'Happy Holidays' text on a pink background

Green patterned cards that say "Happy Holidays" on a blue background

$24.00

Frosty Holidays Greeting Card Set

MY DARLIN

$6.00

Warm Wishes From All Of Us Card

MY DARLIN

$24.00

Union Square Christmas Market Candle

SCENT & SPROUT

Candle in an amber jar with a label on a wooden surface, surrounded by decorative items.

$24.00

Tree Lighting at Rockefeller Candle

SCENT & SPROUT

Sold Out

$35.00

Nordic Nights Candle

GLOW TO GROW

Sold Out

$35.00

Frosted Juniper Candle

GLOW TO GROW

$35.00

Apple Maple Bourbon Candle

GLOW TO GROW

Rectangular cookie cutter and wooden stamp with architectural design on a wooden surface

$36.00

Brownstone Cookie Stamp Set

FRANCESCA FURIAN

Wooden heart-shaped cookie stamp with 'NY' letters next to a baked heart-shaped cookie with 'NY' letters on a checkered fabric background.

$36.00

I Heart NY Cookie Stamp Set

FRANCESCA FURIAN

Evergreen Currant Candle - The WonderMart

$42.00

Evergreen Currant Candle

TRIBE & OAK

$42.00

Citrus Pine Candle

TRIBE & OAK

Hudson Valley Marshmallow Co. strawberry marshmallows packaging on a white background

$8.00

Strawberry Marshmallows

HUDSON VALLEY MARSHMALLOW CO.

Back view of a food packaging with text and nutrition facts on a beige background

$8.00

Salted Caramel Marshmallows

HUDSON VALLEY MARSHMALLOW CO.

Back view of a gray package with nutritional information and branding on a white background

$8.00

Vanilla Bean Marshmallows

HUDSON VALLEY MARSHMALLOW CO.

Sold Out

$15.00

The OG Original Hot Chocolate Mix

HUDSON VALLEY MARSHMALLOW CO.

Sold Out

$35.00

Double Sided Silly Butter Ornament

HIBYE TILES

VISIT US

ADDRESS

SEASONAL HOURS

CUSTOMER CARE

POLICIES

SERVICES

Shop Local From Your Inbox!

Supported payment methods

New Year - New Hours